The Prime Minister, David Cameron, is reported in the press today to be willing to force overweight people to accept treatment or loose their benefits. According to the Mail Online “Obese people could be forced to get help for their ‘treatable’ condition or have their benefits cut.” The Mail Online reports that the Conservative Party is considering a plan to force “almost 2,000 people registered as long-term sick because of obesity” into taking ‘treatment’ for their condition or “face having their benefits docked unless they agreed to lose weight.”
In The Telegraph the Prime Minister is reported saying that “taxpayers should no longer ‘fund the benefits’ of people who refuse to accept the treatment that could help them get back into employment.” According to The Telegraph, David Cameron believes that “It is not fair to ask hardworking taxpayers to fund the benefits of people who refuse to accept the support and treatment that could help them get back to a life of work.” And so “The next Conservative Government is determined to make sure that the hardest to help get the support they need to get them back to a fulfilling life.”
All of which would be understandable if addiction – whether its drugs, alcohol or food – was genuinely a choice and not something that is beyond the rational and reasonable control of individuals. David Cameron is playing with lazy stereotypes and blaming vulnerable people for being feckless, lazy and stupid. A typical Tory stance on social problems then. Lets blame the victims and do nothing to support and correct the underlying problems that people face in regulating what are highly addictive substances.
Blaming people for being obese is like blaming smokers for getting a cough. It is the inevitable consequence of a society that is dominated by a food industry the peddles carbohydrate-overloaded processed foods. These foods are designed to be addictive and the lack of recognition of the dangerous role that sugar and excessive carbohydrates play in our food industries is the real culprit.
Rather than blaming a few people who struggle, lets challenge the supermarkets and the food industry who are making billions of pounds in profits to change their practices, and to stop stuffing their foods with salt and sugar in order to increase their massive profits.
If David Cameron was serious about dealing with the obesity and diabetes epidemic he would bring in a Sugar and Carbohydrate Tax and remove the government subsidies from the processed food industry. He would ban sugary drinks and snacks from schools, and he would stop supermarkets from further decimating the local food networks that allow people to buy fresh food on a daily basis, rather than the long-life processed foods that stack the shelves of the convenience stores.
The nasty prejudice against people who suffer from obesity is clear in Cameron’s attack. It is an attack which isn’t supported by any evidence, and stigmatises addition by linking it with personal morality and will-power. Believe me, I know what it is like to be a carbaholic. It’s a tyranny that is almost impossible to break free from. If David Cameron really wants to do some good he can stop blaming people and set-up the alternative community-based well-being services and food networks that would re-educate people to live without excessive carbohydrates and processes foods.